Cast Vote Records (CVR) Subgroup

This subgroup is creating a common data format specification for cast vote records (CVRs). The specification supports 3 general use cases:

  1. Interoperable exports of CVRs from devices such as scanners, DREs (direct record electronic), or other devices that create CVRs and perform contest rule post-processing. Resultant interoperable import into tabulators, such as election management systems (EMS), or import into auditing systems, or import into adjudication systems.
  2. Interoperable exports of aggregated collections of CVRs from aggregating devices such as EMS.
  3. Interoperable export of CVRs from adjudication devices.
A JSON schema has been generated from the UML model such that scanners and other devices can export and import CVRs in JSON and validate usage against the schema. It should be straightforward to convert the JSON format to other formats such as comma-separated value.

To support auditing, the model contains the following:

  • Support for digitally-signed exports of CVRs.
  • Support for ballot-level auditing, i.e., there is an identifier that can be linked to an ID (identifier) on the corresponding paper ballot provided the scanner creating the CVR can impress an identifier on the ballot as it is scanned.
  • If the scanner does contest-rule post-processing of the ballot selections, indications of what actions the scanner took, e.g., "voter selection overridden by contest rules".
  • Indications of marginal marks, mark quality/density (if scanner is capable).
  • A CVR can include signed/hashed references to an associated image of the ballot or images of write-ins made by the voter on a paper ballot.
  • Improved handling of multi-sheet ballots so that one can more accurately count the number of multi-sheet ballots scanned even if page 1 or any other page is missing.
  • Capability to include batch IDs or other batch information.
  • Support to include adjustments to vote selections made by adjudicators.
For questions, please contact John P. Wack, chair.

Current Status

A use case, model, and XML and JSON schemas have been produced. The model/schema development is in its final stages for publication as a first version, with minor revisions scheduled as a result of meetings with manufacturers.

Working Documents

All working documents are located on the VRI GitHub repository:

usnistgov/VoterRecordsInterchange

Documentation for the VRI model/schema is located at:

https://pages.nist.gov/VoterRecordsInterchange

Membership

Membership in this group is open to all; please add yourself to the membership page and subscribe to the email list, instructions below.

  • Arthur Keller soe.ucsc.edu
  • Benjamin Long nist.gov
  • Chris Hughes fairvote.org
  • Chris Jerdonek gmail.com
  • Danny Casias CO SoS
  • David Cary 3by2.org
  • dmz free and fair
  • Drew Tinney hartic.com
  • Ed Smith clearballot.com
  • Harvie Branscomb election quality
  • Herb Deutsch essvote.com
  • Ian Piper dominionvoting.com
  • Jay Bagga bsu.edu
  • Jerome Lovato CO SoS
  • Jim Canter hartic.com
  • Jessi Romero CO SoS
  • Joe Kiniry Free and Fair
  • John Dziurla democracyfund.org
  • John McCarthy Verified Voting
  • John Wack nist.gov
  • Katy Owens-Hubler Democracy Fund
  • Kenneth Bennett rrcc.lacounty.gov
  • Larry Moore ClearBallot
  • Lauren Massa-Lochridge ieee.org
  • Marko Krstovic dominionvoting.com
  • Mary Brady nist.gov
  • Neal McBurnnett Election Audits
  • Pam Ravesi ClearBallot
  • Paul Aumayr MD Election Director
  • P Frichbourg ES&S
  • Ray Lutz Citizens Oversight
  • Ryan Macias EAC
  • Sam Dana prometheuscomputing.com
  • Tim Halvorsen ClearBallot
  • Tom Caddy Pensec

How to Join:

The email list for this subgroup is vvsg-cvr@nist.gov.

To Join:

Click on the following link and include your full name and email address in the body of the message:

mailto:vvsg- cvr -request@nist.gov?subject=subscribe

You will then receive a confirmation email, to which you must reply.

To Leave:

Click on the following link and include your name in the body of the message:

mailto:vvsg-cvr-request@nist.gov?subject=unsubscribe

To Change Email Address:

To change your email address or for any issues, please send an email to the chair of this working group, John P. Wack.

Policies:

All information exchanged within the WG will be non-proprietary. WG members should assume that all materials exchanged will be made public.

Etiquette:

  • The mailing list is principally for technical discussion related to the Voting System Working Group's activities and not other activities.
  • Include a signature tag on all messages. Include your name, affiliation, location, and e-mail address.
  • State concisely and clearly the specific topic of the comments in the subject line. This allows members respond more appropriately to your posting and makes it easier for members to search the archives by subject.
  • Only send a message to the entire list when it contains information that everyone can benefit from.
  • Send messages such as "thanks for the information" or "me, too" to individuals—not to the entire list. Do this by using your e-mail application's forwarding option and typing in or cutting and pasting in the e-mail address of the individual to whom you want to respond.
  • Do not send administrative messages, e.g., remove me from the list, to the mailing list. Instead, use the links on this page to change your settings or to remove yourself from a list.

Comments

Neal McBurnett has some experimental code to convert this to CSV format, one row per ballot, one column per candidate

-- Neal Mc Burnett - 2016-08-02


Topic attachments
I Attachment History Action Size Date WhoSorted ascending Comment
PDFpdf Branscomb_CastVoteRecords_2v.pdf r1 manage 595.8 K 2017-04-10 - 12:23 JohnWack  
Unknown file formatjson CVR_Schema_V1.0-16.json r1 manage 31.1 K 2017-04-06 - 16:41 JohnWack  
Microsoft Word filedocx CVR_UML_doc_v12.docx r1 manage 632.0 K 2017-03-06 - 17:40 JohnWack  
Microsoft Word filedocx CVR_UML_doc_v16.docx r1 manage 960.3 K 2017-04-06 - 16:41 JohnWack  
PDFpdf CVR_UML_doc_v16.pdf r1 manage 1023.0 K 2017-04-06 - 16:41 JohnWack  
PDFpdf CVR_requirements_for_next_VVSG.pdf r1 manage 347.5 K 2017-04-10 - 12:23 JohnWack  
Microsoft Word filedocx CVR_telecon_notes_01-24.docx r1 manage 14.1 K 2017-03-06 - 17:51 JohnWack  
JPEGjpg CastVoteRecords.jpg r2 r1 manage 604.8 K 2017-03-06 - 17:40 JohnWack  
PNGpng CastVoteRecords.png r1 manage 661.2 K 2016-04-20 - 17:13 JohnWack  
Compressed Zip archivezip CastVoteRecords.zip r1 manage 540.5 K 2017-03-06 - 17:51 JohnWack  
JPEGjpg CastVoteRecords16.jpg r1 manage 669.1 K 2017-04-06 - 16:34 JohnWack  
Compressed Zip archivezip CastVoteRecords16.zip r1 manage 598.1 K 2017-04-06 - 16:35 JohnWack  
Compressed Zip archivezip CastVoteRecordsV5.zip r1 manage 1999.7 K 2016-09-24 - 18:35 JohnWack  
Visio documentvsd ElectronicBallotProcessFlow.vsd r1 manage 58.5 K 2017-04-10 - 12:23 JohnWack  
Visio documentvsd ElectronicVotingFlow.vsd r1 manage 70.5 K 2017-04-10 - 12:23 JohnWack  
Microsoft Word filedocx Initial_use_case_for_cast_vote_records.docx r1 manage 13.6 K 2016-04-20 - 17:13 JohnWack  
PDFpdf Initial_use_case_for_cast_vote_records.pdf r1 manage 531.2 K 2016-09-22 - 19:09 JohnWack  
Microsoft Word filedocx List_of_CVR_model_proposed_changes_not_implemented_yet.docx r1 manage 15.1 K 2017-03-06 - 17:40 JohnWack  
Unknown file formatmdzip NIST_V1.0-16_-_CastVoteRecords.mdzip r1 manage 153.7 K 2017-04-06 - 16:34 JohnWack  
Unknown file formatxsd NIST_V1_cast_vote_records.xsd r1 manage 8.0 K 2016-04-20 - 17:13 JohnWack  
Visio documentvsd PaperBallotProcessFlow.vsd r1 manage 63.5 K 2017-04-10 - 12:23 JohnWack  
Microsoft Word filedocx meeting-minutes-2016-09-22.docx r2 r1 manage 13.6 K 2016-09-24 - 18:28 JohnWack  
Compressed Zip archivezip sample-ballots.zip r1 manage 819.5 K 2017-04-10 - 12:23 JohnWack  
Edit | Attach | Watch | Print version | History: r16 < r15 < r14 < r13 < r12 | Backlinks | Raw View | Raw edit | More topic actions...
Topic revision: r13 - 2017-07-24 - JohnWack
 
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlPLEASE NOTE: This wiki is a collaborative website. NIST does not necessarily endorse the views expressed, or concur with the facts presented on these sites. Further, NIST does not endorse any commercial products that may be mentioned on these sites. All the material on this website is in the public domain, including any text, diagrams, or images, unless indicated explicitly. Don't share anything on this site that you do not want to be public. Do not pass any proprietary documents or put any on the TWiki with implied public disclosure. If you do, it shall be deemed to have been disclosed on a non-confidential basis, without any restrictions on use by anyone, except that no valid copyright or patent right shall be deemed to have been waived by such disclosure. Certain commercial equipment, instruments, materials, systems, software, and trade names may be identified throughout this site in order to specify or identify technologies adequately. Such identification is not intended to imply recommendation or endorsement by NIST, nor is it intended to imply that the systems or products identified are necessarily the best available for the purpose. Any data provided on this site is for illustrative purposes only, and does not imply a validation of results by NIST. By selecting external links, you will be leaving NIST webspace. Links to other websites are provided because they may have information that would be of interest to you. No inferences should be drawn on account of other sites being referenced, or not, from this page. There may be other websites that are more appropriate for your purpose.